Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Error in Keybase SigChain preventing Login #24372

Open
mr-mustash opened this issue Nov 18, 2020 · 2 comments · May be fixed by #24406
Open

Error in Keybase SigChain preventing Login #24372

mr-mustash opened this issue Nov 18, 2020 · 2 comments · May be fixed by #24406

Comments

@mr-mustash
Copy link

Hey all, I've recently been unable to do many things in Keybase, this includes but is not limited to: logging in, retrieving files, cloning repos, and accessing my Stellar wallet.

I finally figured out something was wrong after getting my new phone and trying to sign in to my account. Upon attempting to log in I get the following message from the iOS App, Message wasn't signed. Error code 218: GENERIC in method keybase.1.login.login. I wanted to see if this was reproducible on one of my laptops so I logged out using the macOS GUI, tried to log back in, and got the exact same error.

After that I started to do some digging and found #3064 and #5378 which seemed to be the exact issue that I was having. I tried the following the recommendation other issues in that issue to to run keybase db nuke and that did not help my login errors.

Next I tried to force a login using the --paperkey flag and I had the same results:

$> keybase login --paperkey="f..."
▶ ERROR Message wasn't signed

Anyone will be able to reproduce this error if they even run id on my user:

$> keybase id king 
▶ ERROR Message wasn't signed

If anyone has any tips on how to unfuck my SigChain I would love to hear them. Thanks!
@mr-mustash
Copy link
Author

mr-mustash commented Nov 18, 2020 •
edited

More notes:

My keybase version

$> keybase --version 
keybase version 5.5.0-20200526170801+139bb348af

Other issues where this error has occurred due to SigChain issues

@mr-mustash
Copy link
Author

mr-mustash commented Nov 18, 2020 •
edited

Running keybase -d id king show exactly which signature is failing BTW.

2020-11-18T15:42:25.458533-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 131 Failing key----------
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.22 (Darwin)
Comment: GPGTools - https://gpgtools.org
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=XOL2
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
2020-11-18T15:42:25.458907-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 132 Failing sig----------
-----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE-----
Version: Keybase OpenPGP v0.1.5
Comment: https://keybase.io/crypto
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=JqTx
-----END PGP MESSAGE-----
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459135-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 133 | Failure in VerifySigWithKeyFamily: Message wasn't signed [tags:ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV,ID2=DO2neICozm72]
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459257-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 134 - verifySubchain -> false, ERROR: Message wasn't signed [tags:ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV,ID2=DO2neICozm72]
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459375-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 135 - verifySigsAndComputeKeysCurrent for user 9f225787ae98779492b5235cb8480700 -> ERROR: Message wasn't signed [tags:ID2=DO2neICozm72,ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV]
2020-11-18T15:42:25.459498-08:00 ▶ [DEBU keybase log_ui.go:37] 136 - SigChainLoader#Load(9f225787ae98779492b5235cb8480700) -> (false, ERROR: Message wasn't signed) [tags:ENG=eQFbtT-syZc8,LU=E1a-6cJYQKRV,ID2=DO2neICozm72]

Full log id: 5653bfa8e0806f106c970a1c

@mr-mustash mr-mustash mentioned this issue Nov 18, 2020
Open
@zapu zapu linked a pull request Jan 2, 2021 that will close this issue
Open
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

Change PGPKeyBundle.MergeKey to keep FlagSign keybase/client
1 participant
@mr-mustash